Torn Asunder

November 1, 2026

When routine bites hard
And ambitions are low
And resentment rides high
But emotions won't grow
And we're changing our ways
Taking different roads



On the fifth of June, 2018, Katherine Noel Valentine Brosnahan Spade took her own life. She left a note telling her daughter it was not the little one’s fault. In 1993, Spade her then boyfriend Andy, Elyce Arons and Pamela Bell started the eponymous Kate Spade New York. Relatively affordable and chic, within a few short years every hip young woman on the streets of New York City was sporting a Kate Spade bag. The brand saw enormous success, spawning offshoot labels and opening stand alone outlets. Though the company was started by a group of people, the heart and soul belonged to Kate. She’s the one who came up with the designs, the name and drove the creative direction of the enterprise. It was to say the least, her lifeblood.

‍
With such incredible success comes attention and in the aughts her, the company she had helmed for years was in it’s entirety bought out. What I suspect many non-fashion geeks didn’t know is that they also bought a woman’s name. A term of the buyout was that Kate could no longer use her own name for anything. Per Refinery29 and various Fashionista blogs, it’s reported by the time Kate sold she was ready to be done with the company. The grueling and impersonal requirements of being a megabrand, with megabrand demands took her away from the scrappy creativity which she immensely enjoyed. I did not know Ms. Spade, therefore when those who are in the know say she was unhappy, I write my thesis based off that information. (Sources below.)

Ian Kevin Curtis was the enigmatic frontman of the Manchester band Joy Division. Known for his deep voice, St. Vitus dance and deeply moody lyrical poetry, the man was—is—an icon. At the not-yet-grown age of 23 he took his own life, leaving behind a young daughter and canon of some of the most influential post-punk music to date.

‍
Like most rock frontman, Curtis was shrouded in mystery even when all the details were there for all to see. He married at 19, worked at job centre and according to the film Control, based off his widow Deborah Curtis’ book Touching From a Distance, came to be the lead singer of Joy Division, formerly known as Warsaw, by serendipitously agreeing to be the lead singer and lyricist after attending a historic concert at Manchester’s Lesser Free Trade Hall. Joy division was active for an extremely action packed four years, and in that time Curtis created a legend that outlived himself. Even as he grew wearier, disillusioned and increasingly erratic.

‍

Why is the bedroom so cold?
You've turned away on your side
Is my timing that flawed?
Our respect runs so dry
Yet there's still this appeal
That we've kept through our lives

‍

Very few artists are equally business savvy. There skill lies in their ability to tap in the collective human consciousness, a task that takes from them just as much as it gives to us. For the few that hit major success, they are lucky to have a partner who calls the shots behind the scenes, ensuring deadlines are met and everyone gets paid. From what I’ve read, for the most part Andy Spade was that for Kate, and Joy Division’s manager Rob Gretton was that for Curtis. These side players ensure the lights remain flickering both in the enterprise and their creatives minds. I’ve previously written about the fine line between genius and madness (if I haven’t, do forgive, all shall be rectified), and how maintaining a balance is tantamount to ensuring spiritual and artistic longevity. Creatives need minders for this, whether it be their spouses, business partners or managers, for too delicate is the genius to manage both. Because for those iconoclasts who make it big, someone’s going to want a pound of flesh, and if there’s no one protecting them, they spiral down the hatch of neurosis. The day Kate Spade signed that paper giving away the remaining 44 percent shares of her company, was the day she lost herself. The day Curtis heard Gretton proudly announce ‘we’re going to America,’ (at least based on Paddy Considine and Toby Kebbell’s interpretation’s) was the day the first nail went in.
‍

You cry out in your sleep
All my failings exposed
There's a taste in my mouth
As desperation takes hold
Is it something so good
Just can't function no more?

Again, when speaking of something as personal as suicide, I have to make explicitly clear that I did know either Kate Spade or Ian Curtis. My thesis is based on my recently reading about the former and watching a film about the latter, and noticing similarities in their respective journey’s to the eternal Light. Both suffered from depression, a truly awful disease that should have sufferers treated with more compassion and patience than current society allows. Curtis’ affliction was compounded by epilepsy, and the fatigue and fear he must have felt daily is unimaginable. This noted, was it a chicken or the egg situation for both? Did unprecedented weigh on them so heavily that it exacerbated their suffering? Many people who are quite successful often say that to reach the top doesn’t bring all the joy you expect. For any of us, to lose our selves is the most destructive of human experiences. For the artistically successful it can bring death in all its forms.

‍
What drives people to take their own lives? The answer is deeply personal. Speaking for myself, as the penniless nobody writer that I am, when your life feels no longer in your control, you don’t know how to keep going. For artists who give so much of themselves every day in every way, I think the moment you feel you can no longer make your own decisions or do as you’ve wanted, the only option is eternal silence. Because in the silence is stillness, and in the stillness there is clarity, and in that clarity, you finally see yourself. Yet, we see ourselves in life every day, by seeing, feeling and believing we are loved.
‍

…love, love will tear us apart again
Love, love will tear us apart again
Then love, love will tear it apart again
Love, love will tear it apart again


‍

(If you feel alone please reach out and know YOU ARE LOVED. Call/Text 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline Hours: 24/7)

‍

Kate Spade Sources: https://www.refinery29.com/en-us/2018/06/201040/kate-valentine-spade-name-designer-fashion-career
https://www.smh.com.au/business/small-business/people-are-brands-what-happens-when-a-namesake-leaves-a-company-20180607-p4zjzo.html

Love Will Tear Us Apart lyrics © Universal Music Publishing Ltd. Songwriters: Peter Hook / Stephen Paul David Morris / Ian Kevin Curtis / Bernard Sumner

Heart Image: Yale Medicine website

‍

‍